Why Do I Play Great in Practice but Fall Apart in Games?

Taking Your Practice Game to Competition

The Gap Between Practice and Competition

Summary: Many athletes perform freely in practice but struggle to bring that same confidence into games. Pressure, fear of mistakes, and overthinking skills often cause performance to drop in competition. The good news is that your ability does not disappear on game day. By shifting your focus, training confidence, and using mental rehearsal strategies, you can close the gap between practice and competition and play your best when it matters most.

You might perform great in practice because your skills feel effortless or automatic. You probably play free, confident, and focused in your practice. Then when game day comes, something changes in how you feel and think. Mistakes creep into your mind and confidence drops because of self-doubt. You might start thinking too much about the importance of the event.

This gap between practice and competition is one of the biggest frustrations for athletes. You know you have the talent and the skills to perform well. You’ve proven it in practice, but in competition, pressure and the importance of the game gets in the way.

The good news is that this gap is not about ability. It’s about your mindset changing in competition. You can learn how to bring your practice game into competition.

Why Performance Shifts from Practice to Games

In practice, you feel less pressure when you are working to improve your skills. You focus on drills, repetition, and improving skills. You know mistakes are part of learning and are not worried about them. There are no fans, no stats, no pressure to impress coaches or teammates.

In games, the stakes change or the importance changes for you. You think about results, mistakes, and outcomes and what others might think if you don’t perform well. You play more cautiously because you do not want to fail. Instead of trusting your training, you try to control every move.

This shift in focus to outcome is what creates the performance gap. Your skills don’t change from practice to competition. Your mindset or mental performance does change especially in critical moments.

Mental Barriers That Hurt Competition Confidence

When you lose confidence in competition, it often comes from these mental barriers:

1. Fear of mistakes. You focus on avoiding errors instead of playing to win. Fear makes you tight and hesitant.

2. Worry about outcomes. You think too much about results, stats, or what others will think. This pulls your focus away from execution.

3. Perfectionism. You expect flawless performance. One mistake feels like failure, which hurts confidence fast.

4. Overthinking skills. You try to control mechanics instead of letting them happen naturally. This breaks down trust in your training.

These barriers do not exist in practice because the pressure is lower and they lead to choking in competition. But when competition raises the stakes, they creep in.

How to Bring Practice Confidence into Games

If you want to play like you practice, you must change how you approach competition. Confidence comes from what you choose to focus on before and during games. Start with your mental game. Remind yourself that your skills don’t disappear on game day. You are the same athlete who performed well in practice. The difference is your focus.

Shift your focus to process goals. Instead of thinking about winning, think about controllables. Example: “See the ball early,” “Commit to my routine,” or “Stay aggressive.” Play with trust, not fear. In practice, you let your body perform and try to do the same in games. Avoid analyzing mechanics and instead stay focused on rhythm, timing, and execution.

Use routines to stay focused on the process and be composed. Create a preshot routine that includes breathing, relaxation, and one key focus thought. Routines help you reset and block distractions. The key is to treat competition more like practice with the same level of trust in your skills, not the other way around.

Mental Rehearsal Strategies for Game-Day Consistency

Mental rehearsal bridges the gap between practice and competition. When you rehearse or visualize your game, you train your mind to perform under pressure before the game even starts.

Close your eyes and picture yourself competing. See yourself confident, loose, and focused. Imagine executing the same way you do in practice. Add pressure into your rehearsal: the noise, the crowd, the scoreboard. Then picture yourself staying calm and composed.

Practice this skill often, just like physical drills. The more you rehearse confidence, the easier it becomes to feel it in real competition. You can also rehearse handling mistakes. Visualize making an error, then quickly resetting and moving on. This prepares your mind to stay composed when things don’t go perfectly.

Mental rehearsal is not a replacement for practice. It’s an extra tool to bring consistency from training into competition.

Stop Under Performing in Competition

If you play great in practice but fall apart in games, the problem is not your ability. It’s your mental game misfiring. With mental performance coaching, you can close the gap and compete with the same confidence you feel in training. If you want to stop the frustration and perform your best on game day, book a free session today:


FAQ – Practice vs. Competition Performance

Why do I freeze up in games?

You freeze when your mind shifts from trust to fear. In games, you think too much about mistakes, outcomes, or what others will think. This pressure blocks your natural performance. To overcome freezing, focus on controllables, trust your training, and use routines that calm your body and mind.

How do I transfer practice skills to competition?

You transfer skills by learning to think the same way in both settings. In practice, you focus on execution without fear of mistakes. In competition, you must do the same. Use mental rehearsal, pre-performance routines, and process goals to carry your practice confidence into games.

Why do I play tight in competition but loose in practice?

Tightness comes from trying too hard to avoid mistakes or impress others. In practice, you allow yourself to play loose because the pressure is low. The solution is to build trust in your skills and accept that mistakes happen. Playing with freedom helps you compete at your true ability.

Do professional athletes struggle with this too?

Yes, even elite athletes battle the gap between practice and competition. The difference is they train their mental game as seriously as their physical game. Pros use routines, visualization, and mental coaches to handle pressure and perform consistently under stress.

What is the fastest way to improve my game-day confidence?

The fastest way is to prepare your mind the same way you prepare your body. Start using pre-game routines, practice mental rehearsal, and set simple process goals for competition. Confidence builds from repetition and trust, not from avoiding mistakes.


author avatar
Patrick Cohn, Ph.D. Owner, Master Mental Coach
Peak Performance Sports, LLC is the brainchild of Dr. Patrick Cohn. Dr. Cohn received a Ph.D. is sports psychology from The University of Virginia. Peak Performance Sports is a leader in online mental performance coaching and sports psychology resources for athletes, parents of athletes, and coaches. Dr. Cohn is also the director of instruction for the MGCP sport psychology certification program.

<<Back to Sports Psychology Resource Hub